- Edwin F. Whiting, 1865-1867
- Benjamin F. Batchelder, 1868-1869
- H. Eugene Leland, 1870-1871
- Orrin Thomson, 1872-1873
- George L. Sanborn, 1874, 1877
- Charles C. Abbott, 1875-1876
- Theodore E. Andrews, 1878
- George M. French, 1879-1880
- Ralsemon L. Partridge, 1881
- Nathan W. Philbrook, 1882-1883
- John D. Perkins, 1884-1885
- Frank Cass, 1886-1887
- Harrington C. Kingman, 1888-1890
- George A. Bartlet, 1891
- Joseph H. Morrill, 1892-1893
- John H. Andrews, 1894
- Jarvis B. Woolford, 1895
- Josiah B. Parkim, 1896-1898
- Fred C. Tenney, 1899-1900
- Henry M. Cutter, 1901-1902
- Watson P. Gage, 1903
- Frank O. Young, 1904-1905
- John E. Talbot, 1906-1907
- George T. Robbins, 1908-1909
- W. Eugene H. Phillips, 1910
- Frank E. Travis, 1911-1912
- Alden R. Newhall, 1913-1914
- Clayton T. Joslyn, 1915
- Arthur L. Pond, 1916-1917
- Edgar W. Reemie, 1918-1919
- James Inches, 1920-1921
- Fred B. Wright, 1922
- Howard S. Wells, 1923
- Walter F. Wentworth, 1924-1925
- William R. Phipps, 1926-1927
- George V. Moody, 1928-1929
- Joseph Henry Milligan, 1930
- Thomas A. Gooch, 1931
- Benjamin F. Barnes, 1932
- Robert Briggs Peckham, 1933
- Ernest Albert Smith, 1934
- A. Maurice Merritt, 1935
- Frank L. Pfeiffer, 1936
- Lyle W. Orton, 1937
- Norman S. McCallister, 1938
- Edward A. Lund, 1939
- Alden Leland, 1940
- H. Gordon Weston, 1941
- Edward S. Holbrook, 1942
- Harold F. Ball, 1943
- Charles H. Cole, 1944
- Allan R. Bliss, 1945; DDGM
- Ronald G. Robbins, 1946
- J. Roger Harrington, 1947
- R. Irving Blanchard, Jr., 1948
- Henry A. Chesmore, 1949
- W. Richard Phipps, 1950
- Frederick F. Cole, 1951
- Melvin A. Dill, 1952
- David E. Richards, 1953
- H. Gordon Weston, Jr., 1954
- Norman R. Gillin, 1955
- Charles D. Fisher, Jr., 1956
- Lester C. Potter, 1957
- William K. Jones, 1958
- Norman H. Verkruysse, 1959
- Gordon R. Raymond, 1960
- Oliver A. Raney, 1961
- Richard I. Mitchell, Sr., 1962
- Frederick D.A. King, 1963
- Wilbur A. Wraase, 1964
- Charles M. Abraham, 1965
- Raymond S. Withe, 1966
- Donald J. MacKinnon, 1967
- Martin A. Nitzsche, 1968
- Douglas F. Barrows, 1969
- Gilbert L. Schofield, 1970
- Don C.H. Beebe, Jr., 1971
- Douglas A. Brown, 1972
- Albert T. Beedle, 1973
- D. Craig Travers, 1974
- Samuel P. Blake, Sr., 1975
- Wallace R. Walker, 1976
- Jack E. Anderson, 1977
- David H. Higinbotham, 1978
- Ralph D. Proctor, Jr., 1979
- Joe M. Nelson, 1980
- C. Alan Rowe, 1981
- Carl E. Chellquist, 1982
- Peter B. Low, 1983
- Joseph T. Iwaniec, 1984
- Brenton V. Schofield, 1985
- Theodore A. Hatch, 1986-1987
- Walter J. Waring, 1988-1989
- John C. Mulhall, 1990-1991; DDGM
- Robert A. Smith, 1992
- Alan G. Schofield, 1993
- Kenneth S. Boyd, 1994
- Robert J. Pratt, Jr., 1995-1996
- John M. Nelson, 1997-1998, 2007
- Walter H. Hunt, 1999, 2006
- James E. Tomasetti, 2000, 2010
- Richard A. Casavant, 2001
- Douglas D. Vickery, 2002, 2008
- Louis R. Raneri, 2003
- Scott D. Chalfin, 2004-2005
- Jack M. Olson, 2007, 2009
- Matthew S. Bowie, 2011, 2012
- James L. Holmes, 2013, 2014; DDGM
